Skip to content

Cart

Your cart is empty

Article: Ask the Resident Gent: How to Buy a Christmas Tie Gift for Every Man on Your List

Wrapped gifts on a table including neckties

Ask the Resident Gent: How to Buy a Christmas Tie Gift for Every Man on Your List

The lights are up, the group text about who is hosting has started, and somewhere on your list is a man who, when asked what he wants, said “nothing, I’m good.” He is not good. He owns two ties, one of them is from a funeral, and you are the one who is going to fix it.

We built this year’s Christmas Gift Guide around seven kinds of men and the people who shop for them. To walk you through it we sat down with our Resident Gent, Rob, who has helped more than 50,000 men dress sharp and has never once let a pun go to waste. We asked the questions. He tied up the answers.

AG: Rob, before we get into the seven guys, why is a tie such a hard Christmas gift to buy?

Rob: Because it is a gift for his neck but a test for your relationship. A tie says “I know what you wear, I know what you like, and I know what goes with your navy suit.” That is three things most people cannot confidently say about their own brother-in-law. So they panic, grab something red and shiny at the mall, and he wears it once a year to be polite. Our whole job is to take that panic off the table. You tell us who he is, we tell you what he will wear. No styling degree required.

The ground rules

AG: Give us the rules before we get to the men. What does every tie gift need to get right?

Rob: Three things, and I’ll keep them short because my family tells me I don’t.

Rule one: buy for the man he is, not the man you wish he was. If he has worn navy and grey for twenty years, the hot pink floral is a gift for you, not for him. The exception is the guy who dresses loud on purpose. For him, loud is the love language.

Rule two: a set beats a single. A tie by itself is a question. A tie with its pocket square and lapel pin already matched is an answer. That is all a tie gift set is: the decision, already made. We put sets near the top of every page in the guide because they remove the one thing givers worry about most, which is whether it goes together. It does. We checked.

Rule three: if you are stuck, go darker. Navy, burgundy, forest green, charcoal. A deep color flatters more suits, hides more gravy, and photographs better by the tree. Nobody has ever opened a navy tie and said “what were you thinking.” I have been doing this a long time. I would know.

AG: Anything that should never go under the tree?

Rob: A tie with a cartoon on it, unless he asked. A tie that only works with one shirt he owns. And the words “it was on sale” on the card. The sale is our business. The gift is yours.

The Man Who Has Everything

A wooden drawer filled with neatly rolled neckties in multiple colors

AG: Let’s start with the hardest one. He owns thirty ties. What do you get him?

Rob: The thirty-first, obviously. But it cannot be a tie he could have bought himself, because he already did. For this guy you skip the staples entirely and go one of two directions.

Direction one is what he does on Saturdays. We carry tie bars and lapel pins shaped like the things men actually love: golf clubs, anchors, sailboats, wrenches, saxophones, race cars, a pipe, a pair of barber shears. Put one on a rich textured tie in deep green or rust and you have a gift that says “I noticed.” Men who have everything are rarely noticed. They are usually the ones doing the noticing.

Direction two is for the man who dresses loud on purpose. Bright knit ties in emerald and dijon, floral pins, suspenders in colors that get a comment at the office. He will wear it Christmas morning and again on Monday, and he will tell everyone where it came from.

AG: How do you know which direction he is?

Rob: Look at his socks. If they match his trousers, he’s a Saturday guy. If they have flamingos on them, he dresses loud. If you have never looked at his socks, now you have a reason to visit.

Shop Gifts for the Man Who Has Everything

The Guy Who Hates Shopping

A gift set in a black box featuring a striped necktie in blue, green, and gray

AG: Now the opposite man. Two ties, no interest in a third.

Rob: My favorite customer, because he is the easiest to make happy and the hardest to get into a store. The trick is to never give him a decision. Not “here is a tie, find a square.” Not “here are three, pick one.” You give him a complete tie gift set: tie, pocket square and lapel pin, already matched by us, in a box he can open and put on in the time it takes the coffee to brew.

We keep this whole page in colors that cannot go wrong. Navy, grey, olive, brown, burgundy. Every one of them works with the one suit he owns and the sport coat he borrows from his brother. That is not a guess. That is the entire design brief.

AG: What if he says he will never wear it?

Rob: He said that about the air fryer too. Put the set on the dresser where he gets ready. The first time he has somewhere to be and nothing to wear, it goes on, it looks great, someone compliments him, and now he owns three ties. That is how it starts. I have seen men go from two ties to a drawer in under a year. We call it the gateway set.

Shop Gifts for the Guy Who Hates Shopping

Dad and Grandpa

A styled gift set on a wooden table featuring neckties

AG: The man who taught you to tie a tie. What does he get?

Rob: A better one than he taught you with. And I mean that with love, because my dad’s tie collection peaked somewhere around a wide paisley that could be seen from space.

For dads and grandpas, the rule is classic over clever. Knit ties with a little stripe, herringbone, plaid, the kind of patterns that have been correct for sixty years and will be correct for sixty more. Navy, brown, burgundy, grey. He has worn these colors to every wedding, funeral and Sunday service of your life, and he is not about to start experimenting now. Good. Neither are we.

We put two ties right at the top of this page that were made with fathers and grandfathers in mind. If you want the gift to do the talking, start there.

AG: Beyond the tie?

Rob: Suspenders. Every man over sixty secretly wants a pair and will not buy them for himself. A solid navy or brown pair with the good jacket makes him look like he owns the restaurant. Cufflinks too, simple knot or button styles, for the shirts he saves for holidays. And if he is truly impossible, a set. Dad will say you shouldn’t have. Dad will also wear it to church and tell the pastor where it came from.

Shop Gifts for Dad and Grandpa

The Rising Professional

A man in a dark gray suit jacket and white dress shirt adjusts a patterned blue and beige tie

AG: New job, new title, first real interview. What does his tie rack need?

Rob: A tie rack, to start. Most of these guys have one tie from graduation hanging on a doorknob. The good news is that this is the easiest man to build for, because the office has rules and the rules are on our side.

Start with paisley and dots. I know that sounds like your uncle, but a small paisley or a neat dot in navy, burgundy or forest green is the most grown-up thing a young man can put on. It reads “I belong in this meeting” without reading “I am trying very hard to belong in this meeting.” Then add the hardware: a plain silver tie bar, a white pocket square, a simple pair of cufflinks. Five pieces. He can get dressed for a year on five pieces.

AG: You said five. Which five?

Rob: Two ties, one navy and one burgundy. One silver tie bar. One white pocket square. One pair of cufflinks. That is the starter kit, and it works with a navy suit, a grey suit and the one blazer he owns. If you want to add a sixth, make it a non-iron dress shirt, because nobody taught him to iron and he is not going to learn before Monday.

AG: Any profession this doesn’t work for?

Rob: Lawyers, bankers, accountants, teachers, pastors, real estate agents, the new guy in sales, the resident who finally has a day off. I have yet to meet a job where showing up sharp was a problem. Lifeguard, maybe.

Shop Gifts for the Rising Professional

The Groom-to-Be

A coordinated men's accessory set including a sage green tie, matching folded necktie, folded pocket square

AG: More proposals happen between Thanksgiving and New Year’s than any other time of year. What do you get the guy who just said yes, or just asked?

Rob: The first piece of the wedding look. Not the whole thing, he has months for that and a fiancée with opinions. One piece. A set in the wedding color if they have picked it, or a classic he can wear to the engagement party, the rehearsal dinner, and every wedding he gets invited to for the next ten years, which, once you are engaged, is all of them.

The colors couples are choosing right now are sage, navy, cinnamon and rust, charcoal and champagne. We built the whole groom page from those, so whatever you pick will not fight with the palette when the invitations go out.

AG: Who is buying this gift?

Rob: Usually the fiancée, sometimes the parents, occasionally the best man who wants to get on the groom’s good side before the speech. All three of you are welcome. If you are the fiancée, there is a pair of cufflinks on this page with a lock and a key. I am not going to explain the symbolism. You will know them when you see them.

AG: And when it is time to dress the whole wedding party?

Rob: That is a different conversation and a much bigger box. Our wedding sets are built for exactly that. But that is a spring problem. This Christmas, one great tie and a very good hug.

Shop Gifts for the Groom-to-Be

Father and Son

A blue textured knit tie and matching bow tie laid out on a cream blanket

AG: The Christmas card photo. Talk us through it.

Rob: The most powerful gift on this list, and I say that as a man who has been dressed to match his children against his will. Every adult tie set and bow tie on this page sits right beside its kids version in the same print. You pick the pair. We already did the matching.

Dad gets the full set or a bow tie he ties himself. The boy gets a pre-tied version that clips on in five seconds and survives a toddler, which is a higher bar than most of my ties clear. Navy, dusty blue, sage, olive, brown, rust, and a few florals that look wonderful against a sweater and a reluctant smile.

AG: Does matching have to mean identical?

Rob: No, and the best photos usually aren’t. Same print, different piece. Dad in the tie, son in the bow tie. Or flip it, and let the little guy have the long tie, which he will wear like a scarf and which will be the best picture you take all year. The print does the matching. The pieces give each of them a personality.

AG: Who is buying this one?

Rob: Mom. Almost always Mom. Occasionally Grandma, who has a plan for the photo and is not taking questions. Either way, order early. The small sizes go first, and “we ran out of the matching one” is not a sentence you want to say on December 23rd.

Shop Father and Son Matching Gifts

Gifts Under $30

AG: Secret Santa. Stocking. The coworker. The brother-in-law you drew this year. What works under thirty dollars?

Rob: More than people think, which is why this page exists. A good pocket square, a tie bar, a lapel pin, a pair of suspenders, even a tie. None of it needs a size, all of it ships looking like a gift, and nobody has ever returned a navy pocket square. I checked. Well, I asked. Same thing.

The trick with a small gift is to make it look chosen, not grabbed. So we kept the whole page in the same easy colors as the Hates Shopping guy: navy, grey, burgundy, olive, brown. Whatever you pick will go with whatever he already owns, even if what he already owns is one blazer and a dream.

AG: One piece or a few?

Rob: For the stocking or the office exchange, one. For the guy who deserves a little more but you are still holding to a number, three that go together: a tie, the square that matches, the bar that holds it. That is a complete look for less than a nice dinner, and it lasts longer than the dinner.

AG: Best Secret Santa pick, if you had to choose?

Rob: A tie bar. It fits in a card, it works on every tie he owns, and it is the one accessory most men never buy themselves. He will put it on the next morning and feel ten percent more promoted. That is a good return on sixteen dollars.

Shop Gifts Under $30

Rapid fire with the Resident Gent

AG: He is somewhere between two of these guys.

Rob: Most men are. Shop the one that matches his closet, not his personality. Closets don’t lie.

AG: Tie or bow tie?

Rob: Tie, unless he already wears bow ties. A bow tie is a decision a man makes for himself. A tie is a decision you can make for him.

AG: Skinny or traditional width?

Rob: Match his lapels. Slim suit, slim tie. Dad’s suit, Dad’s tie. If you don’t know his lapels, go traditional. It has never been wrong, only occasionally early.

AG: He already has a navy tie.

Rob: He has one navy tie. He needs two. Trust me, there is a story behind the first one.

AG: Do you sell Christmas ties?

Rob: Not the kind with reindeer on them. The best Christmas tie is one he can still wear in March. Give him a deep green or a burgundy and he gets the season without the expiration date.

AG: Last word?

Rob: A tie is the one gift that gets worn to the moments that matter. The interview, the wedding, the service, the photo on the mantel. You are not buying him fabric. You are buying him a little more confidence on a day he needs it. Pick the man, pick the page, and let us handle the rest. Dress sharp, and tell him Rob says hello.

Rob is the Resident Gent at Art of the Gentleman, where more than 50,000 men have learned to dress sharp without a styling degree. He owns more ties than he will admit to and exactly one pair of flamingo socks.

Shop the full Christmas Gift Guide

Still stuck? Browse every tie, tie set, bow tie, pocket square, lapel pin, tie bar and pair of cufflinks we make, or order by 12/14/2026 for delivery before Christmas.

Leave a comment

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Read more

Man wearing a brown fall suit with complimentary brown tie

Styling up For Fall: A Man's Complete Fashion Guide

Fall fashion for the dapper man. Everything you need to know from the types of patterns to the colors you should add in your wardrobe for this season.

Read more About Styling up For Fall: A Man's Complete Fashion Guide